We have used Pegasus for years for both transfers and hire cars and have never had a problem. Always get a good deal, a good car and a great service. Wouldn't use anybody else.
The way some members of this forum try to push Fethiye Lovers at every opportunity puts me right off them and I wouldn't go near for that sole reason. It's a shame really, there's probably nothing wrong with them, but there is such a thing as too much advertising. It smacks of desperation.