I would echo WordBird and say be open minded about the area you wish to buy in.
We have settled in Ovacik - a place I swore I wouldn't even consider because I made all my judgements of it through the dolmus window. Fortunately for me, I met agents that went out of their way to change my opinion.
Each area has its pluses and minuses and you really need to look round for a while before deciding. Cenk and Olga appear to have a sterling reputation and are Calis experts.
And I would also heartily recommend
http://www.coast2coastpropertiesturkey.co.uk/ and the proprietor Ronnie Higgins and
http://www.index-properties.com/ and the lovely Bünyamin Bulut (known to everyone as Benji). Both guys were excellent in securing us our property, offered us brilliant after sales services and have now become friends.
This forum and the reassurance, experience based advice and amazing support basically ensured we bought here in the Fethiye area. Ask, ask and ask again if something is niggling you or you really can't seem to find the answer. It's what we are all here for.