Can't disagree with anything already said. We've been going to Calis for a few years now but only stayed at the Carretta for the first time last year. And we're back again in May! As has been said before most people you will meet there have been going back once or twice a year, same weeks, same apartment for years!!
If there's anything at all you need when you are there you only have to ask.
It's in an ideal position to get to the promenade and loads of bars/restaurants and shops. Also, the dolmus into Fethiye stops just outside.
We can't wait until we get back there in May!