got to say i use both scarlett and b52 a bit, but i don,t know why the two should be compared. They offer different things, apart from the drinks of course, but i will say i,m happier drinking in b52 as i,ve never seen a fight get out of hand in there, but have seen some nasty fights in scarlett.Sorry but that means a lot to me, i,d rather see glasses being picked up and carried back to the bar than being knocked off the tables or thrown. the boys in b52 sem to be more aware of what is going on and don,t let things develop.