Will be very interested in the reviews, only been to Shaka once, Johns 'signature' Shaka burger was cold, and our friends spaghetti bolognese was like a child's portion and tasteless.
My seafood pasta though was lovely, but in light of the other problems I wouldn't gamble 100 for the 2 of us.
Have eaten at Shine many many times over the past10 years or more, never had a bad meal there, and no, not the same ambience and view but I do think places that trade on their location don't have to try as hard.
I also think one Chicken, one Lamb and one veggie option is very limited and not sure I like the sound of sweet carrot desert.
All personal opinion of course.
Its nice to see a bigger choice of foods coming to Fethiye tough. Yakamoz have recently introduced an Indian menu which sounds really good, haven't had the chance to try it yet though.