I chose Fethiye because you have Fethiye, a year-round working town with lovely marinas, history and views, then the laid back Calis, slightly mad Hisaronu, stylish Gocek, authentic Gunlukbasi, then the merits of Olu Deniz, Uzumlu (yes I do like Uzumlu
), sleepy Yaniklar and rustic (hehe) Koca Calis.
All a stone's throw apart - everything.