Hi donnie, welcome to the forum.
We were in Pefkos last year for a wedding, exactly 10 years after the first time we went there for another wedding! So you can see how much we liked it with 10 years in between visits!
Actually we quite like Pefkos but, after our first visit some friends managed to persuade us to try Turkey and we just fell in love with it and have been coming back ever since. Our main holiday was still in Calis last year with just a week in Pefkos.
Calis wasn't the first place we visited in Turkey but it's the one we keep going back to now. We love it, it's so relaxing and friendly and there's so much to see if you want to get out and about.
I've no doubt you'll love it like everyone else on here.