Really enjoyed reading these comments, I've not been to either of these restaurants, and can't comment. But, what I will say is, I won't be going either. The negative remarks are enough put me off, the power of this forum !
Some may say you shouldn't take any notice and go and judge for yourself, however there are plenty of restaurants that get glowing reviews, so I will play safe and stick to them.
Among my top restaurants are Mosaic Bahçe, Lemon Tree (Hisaronu), Corner Pub (Çalış), Nil Bar, Vojos, Kings Garden, Yacht Classic, Sundial, Receps (fish market), Manceros, Saffron (Ovaçık), etc