Calis Beach and Fethiye Turkey Discussion Forum

Calis Beach Forum => Calis Beach Questions and Information => Topic started by: chris35 on August 05, 2015, 09:28:03 AM

Title: Sea pollution ????
Post by: chris35 on August 05, 2015, 09:28:03 AM
There are some worrying posts on FB regarding the strange colour of the sea at the moment. Has anyone on here noticed it?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 05, 2015, 10:46:35 AM
I've noticed all the bleating going on on Facebook. "The Tourism Dept need to do something about it" "someone needs to issue a statement".

If those people posting on Facebook are that concerned they should go and ask the  relevant people about it as I suspect there aren't any local government employees reading the page and/or passing on the concerns.

If a statement were issued I doubt there would be many of those complaining that were competant enough in Turkish to understand it anyway.

  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: kawasakikid on August 05, 2015, 16:21:57 PM
This is a BIG problem that seems to have got worse over the last couple of years.

I can clearly remember the sea was crystal clear right up to the shoreline. There did not seem to be pollution of any sort apart from a stray reed or two brought down by the river at Yaniklar. The great sea water quality was one of many reasons we decided to move to this area.  Then, a couple of years ago, this all changed. Swimming in the sea was like swimming in a sewerage farm.  It was (and still is) disgusting. At this time, I noticed a beige colour extending several meters out from the shore line.  At first I put this down to the dredging and other canal work that was going on at the time.  But, since this has finished a long time ago, the discolouration remains.

Although it would be hard to prove, I have several friends who have recently swam in the sea at Calis and all of them ended up with very bad stomachs.

I last went swimming at Calis beach about a month ago.  Unfortunately, nothing had changed.  So I am wondering chris35, whether you are seeing what I saw, or whether it has got even worse now.

So the real question should be "who do you need to get in touch with to sort this issue out?"

I do agree that you can talk about this on forums until the cows come home and nothing will change. So who do we go to for something to be done?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 05, 2015, 18:36:56 PM
Seriously worried if this is the case, always swim at Calis!

JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 05, 2015, 23:57:00 PM
Could it be something to do with the increase in large hotels on the shoreline? I heard the Sensatori had been find recently. Not sure how true that is though.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: quackers on August 06, 2015, 05:54:39 AM
Sensatorı were fıned for buıldıng a basement at the hotel wıthout permıssıon.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: philrose on August 06, 2015, 12:03:52 PM
(http://s1.postimg.org/vlff4rd4b/P1030465.jpg) (http://postimg.org/image/vlff4rd4b/)
 Think I'll give the swimming a miss today then.......
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: yabanci on August 06, 2015, 12:40:23 PM
Plenty swimming in it today then. ;D
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: kawasakikid on August 06, 2015, 15:16:27 PM
If you look carefully at the photograph, you can see the discolouration extending out sea up to a certain point. It looks a wierd green now. Perhaps it's algae. If that's the case, then I would suggest the algae is thriving in the water because it is polluted with sewerage.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 06, 2015, 15:21:49 PM
I wonder what effect it has on the turtles ?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: GordonA on August 06, 2015, 15:38:48 PM
 Apparently,  the new Sensatori Hotel has been visited by " persons in uniform " within the last 2 days in connection with this matter, it appears that RAW sewage from that hotel is being discharged directly into the sea !!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: kawasakikid on August 06, 2015, 16:00:52 PM
What would be brilliant if we could get a photograph of the said pipe discharging the sewerage and display on this site.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: JohnF on August 06, 2015, 17:26:39 PM
Whats stopping you?

JF
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 06, 2015, 19:10:55 PM
What would be brilliant if we could get a photograph of the said pipe discharging the sewerage and display on this site.

(https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSyJK9sWDzMUx_QhhoLFqlJacECDdk-dg3XKbz4Odu5goCflZIDQ9NlyT58)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: littlereddevil on August 07, 2015, 13:48:00 PM
That's shocking and not only for people wanting to swim in the sea. Is the beach affected by this?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: true blue on August 07, 2015, 16:58:06 PM
We were at the Bakrac beach bar on Wedenesday and noticed the sea was exactly the same as the picture in this topic.
I actually thought it was sea algae or something similar but when I asked the owner of Bakrac he came right out with it and said it was sewage from the new hotel and told us not to go in the sea until the tide had change later in the afterrnoon.

While we were sat in one of the pergolas 2 people(a man and a woman)came who were apparently from the Fethiye Beledyie and looked at the sea and took photos and a long conversation then took place between them and the Bakrac beach bar owner.

Later in the day the police came and the owner showed them them the sea and also the photos he had taken earlier that morning.

I don't know what happened after this only that we did not go into the water as it was still green where the waves broke on the shore line and also you could unfortunatley see excrement floating in the water.

Hopefully after the 2 visits from the "officials" something will be done very quickly to resolve this problem.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: patrice on August 07, 2015, 17:14:59 PM
Thanks true blue for the update lets hopes something comes of it >:(
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: eldestblade on August 13, 2015, 14:39:05 PM
Anyone have any news on the sea from surf cafe . Has it been treated or back to normal now?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 13, 2015, 14:52:54 PM
Nah, it's still wet.  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 13, 2015, 17:51:41 PM
It's still the same with the interesting colouring.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 14, 2015, 09:23:15 AM
where is the new Hotel?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 14, 2015, 09:59:05 AM
Sounds like you follow the stain to the end and ... there it is!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 14, 2015, 11:03:35 AM
I've just been up parasailing and launched from what I think was the new hotel (which looks to have very good facilities which is just as well as it is completely isolated).

The slick/channel of sewage is really obvious from the air. As we passed over the top of it, under the parachute, I could see the speed boat that was dragging us go through the slick/channel and the brown waves that were created....

Looking behind us the channel was very clear and looks to originate some way out from the hotel. It is taken by the currents down towards Calis mainly but it also appears to go a little the other way too.

Not pleasant to think that people are swimming in that, even if it has broken up a little by the time it hits the shore.

Turtles vs Turtlesheads....
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 14, 2015, 11:57:03 AM
Hmmm think I may change my plans and go somewhere else this year? Seriously this will damage Calis, I was looking forward to swimming there but now will drive over to Gemiler or Olu Deniz instead and have already advised a lot of people I know were planning a late trip to go elsewhere until this is fixed!

Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 14, 2015, 13:14:01 PM
I wondered if this pollution might jeopardize Calis' Blue Flag status. I then found that it is not listed as having one. Is that correct? How does a Turkish holiday resort get away without Blue Flag status? As JT49 remarks elsewhere you might go to Marmaris for decent water. It has always surprised me that Marmaris, which is a busy port with many large cruisers calling, has such good seawater. It is very inviting. In my memory Calis has never been that. When I first starting visiting in the 1990s the manager of the Bambu Bar used to drive to Olu for a swim on his hours off despite being 50 yards from the sea in Calis.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: tamd on August 14, 2015, 17:25:24 PM
If this is spilling out from the new hotel, a I understand it is a Thomson hotel. Surely they should be doing something about this!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Rimms on August 14, 2015, 18:37:31 PM
I have emailed Thompson for comment but without reply, I also submitted a trip advisor question asking about the pollution since the hotel has been in existence. Trip advisor refused to post my comments.

From what I read the local authority are aware of the problem, they can either ignore this and ruin the tourist trade or do something about it. They say money talks? We will see.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: tamd on August 14, 2015, 18:56:15 PM
I will e-mail Thompson also. I don't expect a reply but perhaps if we all do it they might take some notice.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: mercury on August 14, 2015, 19:02:39 PM
From what we have read. The Hotel have issued a denial and say that any problems were about the fact that they haven't got the correct permisions for the basement level. We saw raw sewage in the sea at Calis main Beach and a lower amount at Koca Calis where we always use to swim. This before the Hotel was built but it is so much worse this year.. The Lagoon is also clogged up with grease and sun oil and not all clear later on in the season...
The sea quality in The likes of Greece and Spain are superb compared to Calis.. We have seen the Brown streams coming from the boats from time to time. I thought that this was supposed to have been stamped on.
When going out on the boat trips you have to go quite a way  before you stop seeing the rubbish of bottles. carrier bags etc.. Same with the harbour in Fethiye... A beautiful place like Fethiye shouldn't be the state that the harbour is...
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: apollo on August 14, 2015, 19:08:15 PM
I have emailed Thompson for comment but without reply, I also submitted a trip advisor question asking about the pollution since the hotel has been in existence. Trip advisor refused to post my comments.



I have done the same and have got the same results
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Ali baba on August 14, 2015, 20:52:39 PM
  ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 14, 2015, 21:01:16 PM
Their customers and reps won't see it, it drifts away from them and doesn't hit their beach.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Ali baba on August 14, 2015, 21:13:20 PM
 :(
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 15, 2015, 15:27:29 PM
So are we saying a brand new, multi million pound hotel has been set up to pump sewerage into the sea? I find this hard to believe but if true then why?

Who allowed them to place drainage pipes in the sea and why? Surely they build cess pits for the human waste?

I noticed the colour on a photo a friend put on FB last week. That was the surf cafe. However they have been in the sea every day and not mentioned anything about the colour/quality of the water.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 16, 2015, 13:24:22 PM
Still trying to figure out where this new Hotel is, can someone be so kind as to be a bit more precise for someone who isn't there all year, for example, if I was in front of the Café Bahane looking out to sea would it be to the loeft or right, and how far away, is it for example near Koca Calis?

JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 16, 2015, 13:42:58 PM
It's the next bay round from Koca Calis heading away from Fethiye.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 16, 2015, 14:12:11 PM
So are we saying a brand new, multi million pound hotel has been set up to pump sewerage into the sea? I find this hard to believe but if true then why?

Who allowed them to place drainage pipes in the sea and why? Surely they build cess pits for the human waste?

I noticed the colour on a photo a friend put on FB last week. That was the surf cafe. However they have been in the sea every day and not mentioned anything about the colour/quality of the water.

Who allows them to pump sewage into the sea?  Same people who let them fence off a public beach.  I also remember them pump raw sewage into the river at the back of the place and the Ex-Pats who lived there where up in arms.  There was a lot about it on your Koca Calis F.B. Page.   I remember one guy having a meeting with the Management who offered him a free week at the place.   It seems that they think a free week may buy off people and keep them on their side.  I could not possible comment about this though...   ;) :o :-X
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 16, 2015, 16:14:39 PM
There was one thread on the page Jacqui - with 9 comments. That was back in April. Nothing has been mentioned since to my knowledge. I assume it's been sorted now.

You also didn't answer the question. Who allowed it and why would soil pipes be allowed to be placed in the sea? Surely we have moved on from that - even in Turkey?

Oh - and it's 'were' not 'where'  ;)



Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 16, 2015, 16:27:49 PM
Now, now, Stoop. You know that it is quite permissible on a forum to accuse fellow contributors of having sexual relations with their grandparents or condoning mass murder and similar small offences. But to point out a spelling mistake is to go beyond the boundaries of acceptable forum behaviour and to receive a storm of abuse. Tut, tut. Anyway, after the mistake JH says she did it deliberately to wind up GordonA.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 16, 2015, 16:47:05 PM
Their are far too many wind-ups on this forum. There getting past a joke.. I don't know we're to turn !
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: scorcher on August 16, 2015, 17:01:53 PM
Poor spelling is a result of fast typing I'm reliably informed - nothing to do with knowledge.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on August 16, 2015, 17:04:57 PM
And productive tuxt
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 16, 2015, 17:08:15 PM
Is Jacqui in charge of planning in the region now?

The "authorities" allowed it or were duped by the builders/owners and if so they should be made an example of. Either way it does need to be sorted. As someone else said, perhaps the water discolouration is due to additional algae growth?

It is a disgrace though as looking around from the water taxi and from Kings Garden it really is a beautiful  area. If the powers that be could resist the easy money and maintain very high standards (and pumping raw sewage into the sea isn't) then it could remain as somewhere special.

If they lose sight of that and/or chase the lowest common denominator then it will end up like any other shi@@ole and then the question would be why come here?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on August 16, 2015, 17:13:40 PM

The "authorities" allowed it or were duped by the builders/owners

Hotel Dumps Raw Sewage in Sea - But the Blame Lies Elsewhere

If I'd run a pipe from my sewage pipe into Fethiye bay I don't think "Oh the builder/authorities said it would be ok" is going to get me off the hook!!!

Get real people!!

Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 16, 2015, 17:54:47 PM
I remember that there was a lot of bad feeling on the Koca Calis F.B. page about the Sensatori and it's uncaring management pumping sewage into the river behind the place.  A river that was full of fish and life then it was full of poo.  I know the local ex-pats  became very angry and one guy had written a lot of letters and not had much luck getting any action.  He did get a meeting with the Site Manager and was offered 1 week in the resort, probably to keep him quiet.   The resort also dug up all the local roads with their heavy plant and again made the locals mad as the roads became difficult to drive on.
I have no idea who gave them permission to pump sewage into the sea.  However, perhaps someone can answer the question, who gave them permission to fence off a public beach? I read comments about this on the Koca Calis Forum too.  I am sure if you have the money anything is possible.

As for spelling, who cares, I don't . I type at over 70 w.p.m. always have and I make lots of mistakes my fingers act before I get my brain in gear and will continue to do so. So get used to it folks.    Seems I touched a raw nerve though.  If I where/were/wear defending a big resort at every opportunity even to the point of calling  people I have know for years names, like sh@t stirrers  and trashing them on the Forum we all belong to.  I would also try to deviate from the subject as well, knowing the usual suspects would come in and be tricked into changing the subject from something important to something silly.   
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 16, 2015, 20:27:47 PM
Maybe a local politician was so keen on landing the jobs/economic benefit and kudos associated with a new, large, high-end development from a major industry player in a targetted area he turned a blind eye and moved on before it all hit the fan? He/she might have felt that it's not the best beach in the world anyway so what's a bit more rubbish until it's resolved on someone else's watch/never.

Maybe, the hotel owner got an "independent" marine biology/environmental company to provide an official analysis that determined that the wind/tide/current/local environmental factors meant that the sewage would be broken up naturally and would therefore cause no harm whatsoever? That would enable the local authority to pass the development and subsequently blame the independent "experts" if it were all BS.

Maybe, it will be broken up naturally and not cause a problem 90% of the year apart from peak season and they need to sort that bit of the year out differently?

All hypothetical but possible scenarios. Mostly anything is possible with enough money. Doesn't make it right or pleasant or seem to be a good long term decision for the area.

Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 16, 2015, 20:35:19 PM
As for spelling, who cares, I don't . I type at over 70 w.p.m. always have and I make lots of mistakes my fingers act before I get my brain in gear and will continue to do so.

Ah, so you type all the correct letters, but not necessarily in the correct order.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on August 16, 2015, 20:36:26 PM

All hypothetical but possible scenarios.

All hypothetical scenarios that could perhaps in some way mean the hotel is not at fault.

If the hotel is pumping raw sewage into the bay then the fault lies with them. Not marine biologists, or the local authority, or some long since gone politician, or the builder, or anyone else.

If it is the case that the hotel is pumping raw sewage into the bay, the hotel and the hotel alone is responsible and the hotel and the hotel alone would be held accountable. A big boy did it and ran away doesn't work in Turkey either.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 16, 2015, 20:51:44 PM
I agree Scunner, ultimately the hotel owners are responsible in any event. It's their pipe. I'm merely trying to illustrate how everyone in the loop (at the appropriate time) might know the pipe is there and it be allowed.

It might be perfectly legal. Unpleasant but all signed off and allowed.

I'd hope not as there was a load of it swilling about- it's not an overspill from CBF is it???  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 16, 2015, 23:53:35 PM
So I guess they don't have building inspectors? I would have thought the place would need a certificate or ten before it was allowed to open for business.

Same with the staff accommodation. Who allowed them to build it in the middle of a lake when there is so much land available that would be far more suitable?

My underlying thought is that if they are actually causing the pollution then its more likely through crap workmanship than deliberate actions. Either way it should have been picked up by the building inspectors.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 16, 2015, 23:57:40 PM
I've resisted mentioning your spelling of 'were' as 'where' quite a few times - and if you can type at over 70 words a minute i would expect your spelling to be spot on tbh.  :)
Title: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 17, 2015, 00:06:34 AM
I don't defend the place at every opportunity at all! What planet are you on Jacqui?

My gripe with you and others is that you go out of your way to trash it and those who dare spend their money to go there - at every opportunity.

As for s hi t stirrers - seemed I touched a nerve too. They know who they are and if the cap fits you then you are quite welcome to where it      :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 17, 2015, 09:08:58 AM
The planet I am on is the same planet that a lot of us here on CBF are on with regard to your defence of this resort even to the point of forgetting who your friends are on CBF you think nothing now of alienating people you have known for years just to allying yourself with this new bunch of people who run this F.B. Page.  Well, I hope they will be as good friends with you in the time to come as the people on CBF have been. 



Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 17, 2015, 12:03:09 PM
Well for me Idnto crae atoub spelling from typing to quick or just plain dylsleskik but do care about
going into the sea as healthy as a retired slightly fatty livered overweight pensioner can be and coming out
again with c-dificil, Bubonic Plague and smelling distinctly of sewage to boot. I just wish there
was some kind of proof either way! Definitely wont be coming to Calis again until whatever it is is fixed regardless
of who did it and who has been paid of or not paid off  :)

We had a campaign a while back about attacks on women in Calis and  seem to remember we could email the
Governor in Mugla, could that be somehow applied to this issue? (typed slowly and carefully!)

JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 17, 2015, 12:19:35 PM
The planet I am on is the same planet that a lot of us here on CBF are on with regard to your defence of this resort even to the point of forgetting who your friends are on CBF you think nothing now of alienating people you have known for years just to allying yourself with this new bunch of people who run this F.B. Page.  Well, I hope they will be as good friends with you in the time to come as the people on CBF have been. 



I never forget who my friends are Jacqui because I choose them very carefully. I also have no desire to add more friends to my circle from the Sensatori holiday makers. Why would I? I will probably never meet any of them as I won't be holidaying there.

Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 17, 2015, 12:25:00 PM
Back on topic Johnny - I agree. It needs sorting whoever is to blame.

We go over soon and I won't be swimming in it unless I think its clean.

I've just had friends over who came back on Saturday. I've asked for their input as they were in it every day at the Surf Cafe. They are still alive I think  ;)

I'll relay the answers when they reply.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: nichola on August 17, 2015, 13:01:19 PM
If the new hotel in Koca Çaliş has a pipe taking the sewage out to see then it isn't the only one. Apparently other big hotels in that area and around the Ölüdeniz "purify" their waste and then its taken in aforementioned long pipe and released out to sea.

Personally I think they should all be connected to the main sewage and there is no excuse for new hotels in particular not to be connected at the same time as they are being built and the work should be done to connect those that aren't.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 17, 2015, 13:18:28 PM
OK - I got my reply:

"It wasn't as good as previous years, I don't go in much but M said there were a few poos and bits of debris, I noticed odd paper type stuff in it. That was at surf cafe, we did spend a couple of days at aroma and I didn't notice anything, though I tend to walk round with my eyes closed lol xx@

Also thanks for clearing that up Nichola.

Not good at all! Unless it's sorted then CB could lose even more tourists.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 17, 2015, 14:01:08 PM
I wonder if the owner of Aroma will be considering changing it's name until this is sorted....?

I do wonder at people who seem OK swimming whilst human waste floats by....I have never swam in the sea at Calis in 4 visits and I certainly wouldn't risk my health to do so.

It cannot be a selling point for the resort.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 17, 2015, 14:08:35 PM
Blindside - are you saying that you have seen this before the new hotel was built?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: dycedon on August 17, 2015, 15:35:27 PM
i was swimming at surk cafe last week, as were my grandkids and never noticed any difference.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 17, 2015, 16:13:44 PM
Stoop - no I have never swam in the sea at Calis - only in the pool in the complex where we stay.

I do participate in Open Water swimming (Salford Quays and Chatsworth House in the Great Swim Series and triathlons) and have scuba dived so I'm happy in water. I don't like the beach at Calis due to the stones and the heat and I'm not a lover of lying on a beach anywhere. I like being able to nip into AC to cool down. Salford and Derbyshire are cooler than Calis!

I cannot comment on what the water quality/ratio of turds is normally like in Calis as I haven't even paddled in it. It was only due to someone flagging the potential (recent?) situation whilst I was there (I got back home last night) that I took any interest in it's current state.

The colour of the sea did look different when it was pointed out though. It is a very distinct colour change that I certainly hadn't noticed before in 4 visits. It's not uncommon for Salford Quays or even Windermere to be closed to swimming due to Algae growth so large bodies of water can and do change for that reason.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: apollo on August 19, 2015, 18:50:17 PM
http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/turkey-ranks-second-in-clean-beaches-.aspx?pageID=238&nID=87226&NewsCatID=341
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: GordonA on August 19, 2015, 19:09:46 PM
Now, now, Stoop. You know that it is quite permissible on a forum to accuse fellow contributors of having sexual relations with their grandparents or condoning mass murder and similar small offences. But to point out a spelling mistake is to go beyond the boundaries of acceptable forum behaviour and to receive a storm of abuse. Tut, tut. Anyway, after the mistake JH says she did it deliberately to wind up GordonA.

Hey you, keep me out of this !!  Illiteracy is the big problem in this instance, in my not so humble opinion. Stoop, you go for it mate, and if you ever want lessons in "wind upping", my hourly rates are very reasonable .;-)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 19, 2015, 19:29:11 PM
Don't you mean "winding up" ?  ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 19, 2015, 21:24:13 PM
Don't you mean "winding up" ?   ;)
What, and finish a statement with a preposition? How slovenly.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: scorcher on August 20, 2015, 08:09:10 AM
Ah - Dinnefords was the stuff as I remember......
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 20, 2015, 08:24:51 AM
Don't you mean "winding up" ?    ;)
What, and finish a statement with a preposition? How slovenly.

Yep, I was always the rebel at grammar school !  ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 20, 2015, 10:41:16 AM
http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/turkey-ranks-second-in-clean-beaches-.aspx?pageID=238&nID=87226&NewsCatID=341

Turkey beaches: number 2?

Is someone taking the micky?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: GordonA on August 20, 2015, 16:18:45 PM
Don't you mean "winding up" ?   ;)

I know what I meant !!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: GordonA on August 20, 2015, 16:21:43 PM
Don't you mean "winding up" ?     ;)
What, and finish a statement with a preposition? How slovenly.

Yep, I was always the rebel at grammar school !   ;)

With a cause ?............. Alan ,u cld of gone 2 are skool, in Liverpool !!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 20, 2015, 16:31:44 PM
Have you got a good recipe for lasagne ?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: mercury on August 20, 2015, 18:24:40 PM
Oooh KKOB...dangerous ground there. x
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 20, 2015, 18:41:07 PM
Danger is my middlename. (Despite the fact that Mrs KKOB swears it's Dick'ead  ;) )
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 20, 2015, 18:45:42 PM
Well I'm out here in Koca and local rumour is that it's the staff accommodation blocks causing the pollution.

Personally I can't see that myself as its a long way for poo to travel but you never know.

I also have a wonderful lasagne recipe. I'll post it sometime - in the correct section of course.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: mercury on August 20, 2015, 19:38:52 PM
Take my advice Stoop. don't send a lasagne recipe... Loz has the best one doesn't she Gordon.??
Bodies travel miles in the sea currents Stoop. A fe brown lumps is nothing...Typical blaming the staff..
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 20, 2015, 20:02:00 PM
I read on here recently that the Sensatori had been fined for polluting the water.   It did not mention the staff block.   If it was the staff block then the water in Koca Calis must be badly polluted.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: jackstee on August 20, 2015, 20:44:58 PM
They were fıned 80 millıon for bulding a basement level whıch wasnt ın the planning permisıon

Sorry new turkısh keyboard
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on August 20, 2015, 20:56:51 PM
80 million Steve?

As in 17 and a half million pounds?

No wonder they charge for sunbeds!!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Liz 101 on August 20, 2015, 21:12:48 PM
Fined 8,271,000 tl for an illegal basement. 4,132,000 for the construction co & the balance payable by Barut, owners of the Sensatori. In addition they have been fined 80k tl by the coastguard for sea pollution
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on August 20, 2015, 21:22:07 PM
Thanks Liz - still a hefty fine. I wonder if, once they pay it, they can use the basement.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 20, 2015, 21:26:06 PM
Yes, they could pump the sewage down there.   
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Liz 101 on August 20, 2015, 22:05:15 PM
Maybe it was the cess pit on the original plans  :(
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: lissa on August 21, 2015, 18:08:36 PM
Not been to Calis beach for while. Is the sea still a green colour? Surely it does not matter which block at Sensatori is responsible for this pollution, staff or hotel guests, still the hotels responsibility......
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: lissa on August 21, 2015, 18:09:32 PM
Not been to Calis beach for while. Is the sea still a green colour? Surely it does not matter which block at Sensatori is responsible for this pollution, staff or hotel guests, still the hotels responsibility......
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 21, 2015, 18:23:05 PM
Am I watching Dave Ja Vu ?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: tamd on August 21, 2015, 18:33:09 PM
So ... Is the outcome just the same - raw sewage being pumped into the sea? The prices they charge they will just keep paying the fines.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 22, 2015, 18:52:40 PM
No idea. We will take sea photos soon. It does sound very nice at the moment though as I eat my meze  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 22, 2015, 20:30:07 PM
Yes, Stoop, but have you had a swim at Koca Calis amongst the Sensatori poo???
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 22, 2015, 20:41:28 PM
Very rarely do the sea here due to the stones.

Might paddle in it and catch a few just for you  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 22, 2015, 20:55:17 PM
Images please and do put them on the Sensatori F.B. and see how long they last... Sorry, wait a minute, if you do that you could be banned!!!  Fairyland does not tolerate any true postings.   :) 
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on August 23, 2015, 18:20:32 PM
I'm absolutely shocked and disappointed to read all this about the beaches in Calis and Koca Calis. We plan to be there in 3 weeks and it's always been a delight to swim in the warm waters at both beaches. Don't think I'll dare now. Do hope desperately that the situation will be fixed - and steps taken to stop the Senatori hotel pumping raw sewage into the sea. Unbelievable!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: lissa on August 23, 2015, 19:27:53 PM
Dave Da Vue?? KKOB, what do you mean? The fact that I posted the same comment twice or because it has been discussed before? Surely a topic that should be discussed and more importantly addressed? I just find that a silly response on such an important subject.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 10:08:52 AM
Just posted this on Sensatori page

Is it true that the Hotel is pumping raw sewage into the sea from the Hotel? I have heard reports that it can be clearly seen and is polluting the water as far as Calis? I heard that the Hotel has been fined for this but is still doing it? Is this true?

Lets see  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Toky on August 25, 2015, 10:38:47 AM
Prepared to get kicked off it.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 11:44:09 AM
Of course but I wonder what would happen if everyone who reads this did similar? Deluged the site  :) ?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: kevin3 on August 25, 2015, 12:07:08 PM
  And why not. They've deluged the sea with  Richard the thirds.    >:(   Perhaps they should re name the hotel  " The Lavatori "
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: JohnF on August 25, 2015, 12:19:27 PM
Of course but I wonder what would happen if everyone who reads this did similar? Deluged the site   :) ?


They'd block you, so to speak...

However, if everyone posted on here and used within the post the key phrases "sensatori fethiye review" or "sensatori turkey review" then given this sites credibility with Mr Google, this thread would start appearing on page one.   :)

JF


Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: apollo on August 25, 2015, 12:50:11 PM
The reply which I have  just received from Thomsons.

Thank you for your further email.

We have just had a response back from our resort office.

They have advised, they have seen the comments on social media sites and have spoken to the hotel and they have also seen the comments.

They say that they do a lot of work for the environment and are working towards getting a Travelife award and are aware of things that can help to improve the environment.

Thanks again for contacting us and letting us know your thoughts.
 

Kind regards,

Alison Cooksley
Customer Service Advisor
Thomson Holidays
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on August 25, 2015, 13:10:22 PM
I'll die laughing (if I don't from swimming in waters polluted by Sensatori Hotel). :o
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: jrichards1 on August 25, 2015, 13:48:55 PM
I don't really understand Thomsons reply
I do a lot for the environment and am aware things can help to improve it. I'm not pooing in the sea though.
Perhaps that's what the Travelife award is. Who can poo the most and see how far it travels.

Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 14:34:17 PM
Of course but I wonder what would happen if everyone who reads this did similar? Deluged the site    :) ?


They'd block you, so to speak...

However, if everyone posted on here and used within the post the key phrases "sensatori fethiye review" or "sensatori turkey review" then given this sites credibility with Mr Google, this thread would start appearing on page one.    :)

JF




Well, actually not, check...my post is still there, well it6 was 30 seconds ago, come on everyone post similar  :)

JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 14:35:24 PM
Of course but I wonder what would happen if everyone who reads this did similar? Deluged the site     :) ?


They'd block you, so to speak...

However, if everyone posted on here and used within the post the key phrases "sensatori fethiye review" or "sensatori turkey review" then given this sites credibility with Mr Google, this thread would start appearing on page one.     :)

JF




Well, actually not, check...my post is still there, well it6 was 30 seconds ago, come on everyone post similar   :)

JT
annd to be sure .....  https://www.facebook.com/pages/Sensatori-Resort-Fethiye/372512472947092?fref=ts

JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 14:36:54 PM
The reply which I have  just received from Thomsons.

Thank you for your further email.

We have just had a response back from our resort office.

They have advised, they have seen the comments on social media sites and have spoken to the hotel and they have also seen the comments.

They say that they do a lot of work for the environment and are working towards getting a Travelife award and are aware of things that can help to improve the environment.

Thanks again for contacting us and letting us know your thoughts.
 

Kind regards,

Alison Cooksley
Customer Service Advisor
Thomson Holidays

her email address please? Again lets all write! moor momentum! JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: AOK on August 25, 2015, 16:04:18 PM
The reply which I have  just received from Thomsons.

Thank you for your further email.

We have just had a response back from our resort office.

They have advised, they have seen the comments on social media sites and have spoken to the hotel and they have also seen the comments.

They say that they do a lot of work for the environment and are working towards getting a Travelife award and are aware of things that can help to improve the environment.

Thanks again for contacting us and letting us know your thoughts.
 

Kind regards,

Alison Cooksley
Customer Service Advisor
Thomson Holidays

Corporate Bull**** for 'We don't Give a Toss'
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: JohnF on August 25, 2015, 16:14:34 PM
Of course but I wonder what would happen if everyone who reads this did similar? Deluged the site     :) ?

They'd block you, so to speak...

However, if everyone posted on here and used within the post the key phrases "sensatori fethiye review" or "sensatori turkey review" then given this sites credibility with Mr Google, this thread would start appearing on page one.     :)

JF

Well, actually not, check...my post is still there, well it6 was 30 seconds ago, come on everyone post similar   :)

JT

Trust me, if folks started flooding their FB page with negative posts they'd remove the posts and block every one who did so.  There is no such thing as "free speech" but at least here you don't get binned for not following the party line, well most folks don't  ;)

JF
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 16:37:01 PM
OMG!! You mean they would block me from the Sensatori site? What can I say, the soles of my boots quake in fear, my pupils are dilated with terror, i could even get banned from the local Library reading rooms? A fate worse than death.....perhaps not!

And ............it is still there!

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Sensatori-Resort-Fethiye/372512472947092?fref=ts

I actually tried to find anything on google about Sea Pollution in Calis, the Sensatori polluting the sea, a ll I got was CBF so.............looks like the Worlds search engines don't sit holding their breath for what will appear on CBF to make sure the World knows does it?  :)

Me? Cynical?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Anne on August 25, 2015, 16:47:56 PM
Don't see your post there John
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 16:52:30 PM
Don't see your post there John
its here!?? https://www.facebook.com/pages/Sensatori-Resort-Fethiye/372512472947092?fref=ts

JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on August 25, 2015, 16:55:06 PM
Can't find any posts about sea pollution. Have looked twice in last few minutes
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 25, 2015, 17:02:04 PM
Think you've become a nonperson lad (USSR circa 1935).
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: JohnF on August 25, 2015, 17:06:18 PM
OMG!! You mean they would block me from the Sensatori site? What can I say, the soles of my boots quake in fear, my pupils are dilated with terror, i could even get banned from the local Library reading rooms? A fate worse than death.....perhaps not!

And ............it is still there!

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Sensatori-Resort-Fethiye/372512472947092?fref=ts (https://www.facebook.com/pages/Sensatori-Resort-Fethiye/372512472947092?fref=ts)

It wasn't when I looked as well, just didn't want to burst your bubble by telling you so.

I actually tried to find anything on google about Sea Pollution in Calis, the Sensatori polluting the sea, a ll I got was CBF so.............looks like the Worlds search engines don't sit holding their breath for what will appear on CBF to make sure the World knows does it?   :)

Stop being an arse.  While no search engine holds its breath for any web site, you can be assured that content on CBF is indexed (by Google, Yahoo & Bing) within a day or so.  Hence all you got when you searched was....  CBF!

JF
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 17:07:30 PM
There are two Facebook pages, one in english and the other seems mainly Turkish
so have posted on BOTH

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Barut-Hotels-Fethiye-Sensatori/792686007505237?fref=ts

JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 17:11:47 PM
Think you've become a nonperson lad (USSR circa 1935).
Thought that b*****d Trotsky might have tipped me off..... sigh, there is no decency in the post revolutionary Politburu any more!

Its enough to make you seek Asylum in the UK and vote Tory!

 :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 25, 2015, 17:16:23 PM
No, not there.   Ask Stoop to post for you, as his posts are never deleted and he has not been banned.
Wait a minute, he might say this is sh@t stirring  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 25, 2015, 17:41:19 PM
Anybody seen JT49? Why hasn't he posted anything on CBF for the last fortnight?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 25, 2015, 18:36:34 PM
I have been away .........................but I am better now  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Menthol on August 25, 2015, 19:26:01 PM
ArtyMar and I have added to your post on the Turkish Facebook for the Sensatori Fethiye Turkey Review page.

I said, 'We have added to your post about the sewage allegedly pumped into the sea from the Barut Group Hotel, Sensatori Fethiye Turkey'


Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on August 25, 2015, 20:50:20 PM
I posted the following reply to your post, JT49:

If so, absolutely shocking. I trust this will be stopped, or the hotel closed. One hotel should not be allowed to ruin holidays for thousands or to endanger health of innocent tourists.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Menthol on August 25, 2015, 20:57:56 PM
ArtyMar and I have added to your post on the Turkish Facebook for the Sensatori Fethiye Turkey Review page.

I said, 'We have added to your post about the sewage allegedly pumped into the sea from the Barut Group Hotel, Sensatori Fethiye Turkey'

That was me doing an Arkwright above.

I actually put on the facebook page : I have also heard about this and so bad was the pollution from this hotel that the sea changed colour! How can a 5 Star luxury hotel be happy to allow their guests to swim in sewage. Please also note that the beach is supposed to be protected to allow the breeding and nesting of the turtles. Is this really true?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Toky on August 25, 2015, 21:02:36 PM
It's worth noting that the link to the Sensatori is an unofficial  page, The real one has scores of postings per day and you have to join that group.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 25, 2015, 21:28:35 PM
This is the link to the page you must join and will be instantly banned if you write the wrong thing.
https://www.facebook.com/sensatorifethiye
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Toky on August 25, 2015, 21:33:46 PM
https://www.facebook.com/groups/273284966140574/
This is the link and if you are banned permenantly, it'll say "Content currently unavailable"
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 25, 2015, 21:55:27 PM
Well we were down at Koca Calis beach yesterday and the water looked fine from where I was. No discolour like the other week. Lots of people swimming and enjoying themselves.

If it's the same next time I might even venture in for a closer inspection. If I see any foreign bodies I'll let you know.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Highlander on August 25, 2015, 22:08:11 PM
Safer than swimming pools in St Andrews then  ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Anne on August 25, 2015, 22:35:50 PM
(http://i111.photobucket.com/albums/n151/mypaperplace/Untitled_zpsru8nx55i.jpg)

banned within minutes
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 25, 2015, 22:40:43 PM
Anne you are a sh@t stirrer everyone that gets banned is  :) 
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: MarKar on August 25, 2015, 22:45:56 PM
just returned from telemessos, we didn't use the beach much this time due to the current problem but a family staying on our complex said they had seen evidence of raw sewage on about 4 separate occasions (not sure why they kept going) they were using the section up by Guvens  as they like it there.

markar
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 26, 2015, 10:24:58 AM
Have asked to join... it is taking off, people are commenting!

Chris N Daina Thompson The pool looks lovely and clean. Shame the sea in front of the hotel and as far as Calis is full of human excrement that is being pumped out of this hotel. Just so you know when you decide to fork out a fortune to stay here.

I am sending a FB Message to anyone who has posted. I too wrote to Thomson at cares@thomson.co.uk

Ahh good, well got a load of posts and comments out before they kicked me off  :)

Now. letters to the travel writers of all the National Newspapers being posted this  morning!

JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on August 26, 2015, 11:10:09 AM
Wow, JT49 - that's what I call action!

Sadly, I fear a) Thompson have the money to give back handers to any officials with any power to do anything and
b) the cost of doing whatever is necessary will be immense and take time with consequent income loss to Thomson related to lack of guests not to mention pay-off to staff/compensation to holiday makers. Thompson may do an analysis of cost v benefit to themselves and decide in favour (naturally) of themselves.

A national newspaper campaign could have a major effect on Turkish tourism in general - therefore the issue should be brought to the highest Tourism authority in Turkey who may be able to override locals. Maybe . . .but unless the campaign was big and well coordinated (or at least the threat of such), there may be general 'tut-tutting' but no action.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 26, 2015, 11:57:10 AM
Well, started with the Guardian. Lets see!

Perhaps 10,000 leaflets to be distributed at all UK Airports, leaflet distributors outside Media City Salford etc.
Wont get anything achieved until next year but...................

I am going to work on finding out exactly who is involved in ownership of the Barut Fethiye Sensatori .....suspect local Politicians involved!



Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 26, 2015, 13:51:13 PM
I believe Simon Callder is the Tourist Information / Holidays Editor in the Guardian.  He is always on T.V. so perhaps if you have written to the Guardian, he will pick this up?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 26, 2015, 15:22:46 PM
As I said above. The sea looked ok from Max's place. None of the discolour I saw on photos taken a few weeks back.

Maybe action has been taken? Maybe the colour was indeed caused by something else?

For your info John, Barut is a massive company in Turkey.  They have built many huge hotels and seem to have the councils in their pocket.  I'd tread carefully before I started throwing my weight around - especially if you own a place out here.



Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 27, 2015, 13:13:30 PM
Well, well, someone I know in  the Travel industry tells me that this issue finally got to the right level
and "something is being done", so lets see  :) I am out in mid October so will look for myself and take some
samples for analysis.

Thomson may finally have put pressure on  :)

Might still wear a dry diving suit to swim though  :)  :)

JT
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: patrice on August 27, 2015, 14:20:20 PM
Well done JT for  your commitment in pursuing this dreadful issue
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on August 27, 2015, 15:15:26 PM
I emailed customer care in Thomson and got this reply:

<<Thank you for your email.

I have spoken to resort and they have advised this has been looked into. Please bear with us whilst we wait for a response.

Kind regards,

Joshua Howells
Customer Service Advisor
Thomson Holidays >>
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 27, 2015, 15:46:46 PM
I believe Simon Callder is the Tourist Information / Holidays Editor in the Guardian.  He is always on T.V. so perhaps if you have written to the Guardian, he will pick this up?

It's Simon Calder, and he's the Senior Travel Editor for The Independent.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 27, 2015, 18:19:39 PM
Whatever, but he would be the one to contact as he is never off the T.V.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: curvanord on August 27, 2015, 21:20:58 PM
Have corresponded with Thompsons and was given this reply...

Thank you for your email.

I can confirm that this is untrue, several weeks ago a local Turkish man made claims to a journalist that we are running sewerage into the ocean and the journalist ran with the story. The journalist issued an apology in the paper on the 30th June 2015 confirming that his original story was untrue but unfortunately by this time, the rumours had already caught on.

The hotel has a filter system that filters dirty water into clean water which is then used to water the grass next to the hotel. This is common practice for many hotels and is done correctly. We also have a drainage pipe which goes into the forest but this is used only for rain water. The hotel does not have any pipes that go into the sea.

The local government authorities make regular visits to this hotel to regularly test the water and ensure the hotel is adhering to all the correct guidelines and we also have staff members whose job is to ensure the filter system is working correctly at all times.

I hope this provides clarification and if I can assist with anything further, please let me know.

... Hopefully this is accurate and not a fudged reply...
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 27, 2015, 22:11:13 PM
One would hope a new hotel of this quality would have those things in place.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 27, 2015, 22:43:56 PM
I'd have thought that, if they'd built a pipe out into the bay to discharge sewerage, someone would have noticed the construction going on.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 28, 2015, 08:05:31 AM
Fined 8,271,000 tl for an illegal basement. 4,132,000 for the construction co & the balance payable by Barut, owners of the Sensatori. In addition they have been fined 80k tl by the coastguard for sea pollution
 ----------------------------------------------------
Does anyone know why the the 80k tl  ????   and why the Thomson's message made no mention of this???
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on August 28, 2015, 09:03:06 AM
Reading the Thompson rebuttal statement prompts me to ask a question that has been worrying me for some time.......... and has just been asked by KKOB

Where is the pipe that is allegedly discharging into the sea ?? Did anyone see them installing it across the beach ??

Presumably it would have been a large pipe requiring a large trench to be dug. Given the contours of the land I think it would have to be a pretty deep trench by the time it got to the sea to allow for sufficient downhill gradient ? In theory it would also have to go some considerable distance out from the shore and this type of pipe usually becomes visible after a while.

Where is the actual outflow into the sea ??

I think it would actually have been cheaper to install a small filtration system instead of laying in the pipe ?

Any clues anyone ?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on August 28, 2015, 09:19:17 AM
I heard they take it out in plastic cups
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on August 28, 2015, 09:32:22 AM
Stand by.......there will now follow lots of Efes recycling jokes .............. "So that's where Efes comes from."  ....... etc
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 11:44:36 AM
Well I'm at Koca Calis beach now. The wind is blowing off the sea a heck of a pace. The sea is a different colour for at least 200 yards out which is obviously caused by the sand being churned up ( trust me I'm a fisherman ).

I've just walked about 100 yards in both directions and only seaweed is being washed up. I would have expected to see any nasties as well but there is nothing.

Not defending anyone but I've yet to understand why a multi million pound hotel would discharge human waste into the sea. I think there's much more chance it's the odd boat coming back to Fethiye that is discharging it's waste where it shouldn't.

Great thoughts about the pipe as well. Did anyone see it being laid? Also does anyone have an actual link to the reports on the fines?

Ask said earlier - locals are saying it's the new staff block causing the problem but I have my doubts about that even more. It's a good half mile to the sea from there and I can't see them going to the trouble of laying a pipe that far when there are far cheaper options.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 12:16:03 PM
I've just spoken to a bar owner on the front and he's adamant it's the boats discharging their waste. He's complained to the ministry about it.

Maybe getting rid in port has risen in cost and some are not willing to pay it?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 12:21:34 PM
I've just spoken to a bar owner and he's adamant the problem is being caused by the boats discharging their waste at sea rather than pay to do so in port.

In fact he's complained to the tourism ministry about it as it's obviously going to affect business.

So the plot thickens  :)

Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on August 28, 2015, 12:53:09 PM

The more you think about the idea of pipe, the more and more unlikely the idea that one exists becomes.

Given the location of the hotel the (rather long) route of any pipe to the sea would have to cross land that they do not own. Even in Turkey this would be a difficult thing to do.

The pipe would have to cross the beach road. The disruption during the installation would have been immense. I have seen the result of pipe laying elsewhere and there would now be a massive scar on the road and the landscape where the pipe was laid.

I think it is time to assume that no pipe exists and before there is any more chucking of brown stuff the facts should be checked much more carefully............. as an owner of a hotel, publicly and falsely accused of being the cause of the problem I think I might get quite upset............ I might even consider legal action........


Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on August 28, 2015, 13:07:38 PM
I've just been up parasailing and launched from what I think was the new hotel (which looks to have very good facilities which is just as well as it is completely isolated).

The slick/channel of sewage is really obvious from the air. As we passed over the top of it, under the parachute, I could see the speed boat that was dragging us go through the slick/channel and the brown waves that were created....

Looking behind us the channel was very clear and looks to originate some way out from the hotel. It is taken by the currents down towards Calis mainly but it also appears to go a little the other way too.

Not pleasant to think that people are swimming in that, even if it has broken up a little by the time it hits the shore.

Turtles vs Turtlesheads....
[/quote

Although this post suggested opposite? Blindside??

J
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on August 28, 2015, 13:24:06 PM
Sorry to say that the quoted observation PROOVES nothing at all.
Stoops observations today contradict it totally.

"False accusations always lead to false smears"
(Loosely adapted from a George Soros quotation)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 28, 2015, 13:44:09 PM
So, why no answer to my question?  This resort was fined 80K TL by the Coastguard for polluting the sea water. So, what did they pollute the water with?.  :-\

It cannot be denied that they have been fined so they are guilty of polluting the sea water, whether they have a sewage pipe or not, they must have put quite a lot of "matter"  into the water to be fined.  :(

Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 28, 2015, 13:55:00 PM
Is there a link to confirm this?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on August 28, 2015, 14:33:00 PM


And no answer to my question either .........

Where is the pipe ? (or any evidence of any sign of a pipe having been installed)

IF the Coastguard are responsible for monitoring coastal pollution, IF they have power to impose such fines, and IF a fine has been levied, however the hotel caused any pollution it was not via a pipe into the sea.

Given the size of the hotel, if they were discharging all their untreated human waste into to the sea (which has very little tide) the beaches would be knee deep in the stuff by now, as well as being littered with dead marine life.

The Thompson rebuttal statement is quite clear “The hotel does not have any pipes that go into the sea.”  ( What grounds are there for not believing this, but accepting FB posts as being gospel ? )

My last comment on the matter is that until someone can post a photo showing any sign of a pipe existing or having been installed then it would be wiser to assume it does not exist.

I will eat humble pie if someone proves me wrong.


Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 14:33:02 PM
The brown 'slick' is the sand churned up by the waves and high winds. Where the water gets deeper it disappears. That's how it works on the coast.

Last week it went out about 50 feet. Today it's 200 yards plus! That's a hell of a lot of crap!

I prefer to take notice of a bar owner who has lived and worked the area for the last 8 years and Calis itself much longer. I think he will know more about the sea here than any of us on this forum. If he says it's the 12 Islands boats dropping their load, so to speak, then I would tend to believe him tbh.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 14:33:28 PM
Link to the fine Jacqui?
Title: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 14:52:23 PM
Interesting how much they seem to spend on re-using waste. Not saying I think they are anywhere near brilliant but they seem to think they are:

http://www.baruthotels.com/en/baruthotels/environment

And how much cruise ships dump in the ocean :

http://factually.gizmodo.com/cruise-ships-dump-a-billion-gallons-of-sewage-in-the-oc-1668307131
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 28, 2015, 15:12:08 PM
Link to the fine Jacqui?

The below piece was posted by Liz 101 who lives in Calis and I have not reason not to believe her.

Re: Sea pollution ????
« Reply #79 on: August 20, 2015, 21:12:48 PM »
Fined 8,271,000 tl for an illegal basement. 4,132,000 for the construction co & the balance payable by Barut, owners of the Sensatori. In addition they have been fined 80k tl by the coastguard for sea pollution
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on August 28, 2015, 15:15:26 PM
So no proof a fine either......................
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 28, 2015, 15:26:04 PM
Well, we don't know that.  I know Liz and would not think she would make up stories.  I hope she may get back and clarify this matter.   As I don't live in the area and neither do other members arguing for this resort.  I tend to take the word of a local.
In the meantime, there is no way I would allow any of my family to dip their toes in the water.  No matter how many people seem to want to defend this place.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 15:30:43 PM
Stories never get 'made up' in Calis/Fethiye do they

I'm not saying Liz made anything up but stories here go round like Chinese whispers.

As for believing a local - why don't you believe one who has lived here all his life and runs a beach bar every single day?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 28, 2015, 15:37:49 PM
If there was a fine it would be relevant to know when that was. The peculiar sea colour was reported on here on August 5th. Now I know that Turkey is a paragon of speed and efficiency in administration but, even so, for the coastguards to have detected it, determined the source and levied a fine in two weeks seems surprising. Perhaps a fine was raised during the building process and unconnected to present pollution concerns.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on August 28, 2015, 15:39:49 PM
I am afraid that the history of Calis is littered with the debris of stories which have originated from the “word of locals” exchanged and passed on in bars, restaurants and cafes.

I think history will prove that this is another one of them.

( A wise man (who I think runs a forum) is reported to have said "When in Calis believe nothing, unless you have actually seen or witnessed it yourself. "  But I have never heard him say it - so it may not be true)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 28, 2015, 15:48:07 PM
Even by Turkish standards the figures mentioned for the fines seem pretty outlandish.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 28, 2015, 15:55:25 PM
Stories never get 'made up' in Calis/Fethiye do they

I'm not saying Liz made anything up but stories here go round like Chinese whispers.

As for believing a local - why don't you believe one who has lived here all his life and runs a beach bar every single day?




Some would say that if someone ran a beach bar they would tell the tourists that everything is fine. I make no comment   :D
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 28, 2015, 15:59:36 PM
But he didn't say every thing is fine. Instead he said it was polluted with the discharge of sewage by boats.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: yabanci on August 28, 2015, 16:48:29 PM
Link to the fine Jacqui?

The amount of fines were taken from an article published in the Sun Express free newspaper dated 3rd-9th August 2015.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 28, 2015, 17:19:37 PM
Got to like a newspaper with a headline that says "Squirrels to Extinguish Fire" (Sun Express, 17 August 2015).
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 28, 2015, 21:08:57 PM
So, basically, if one newspaper has a frivolous headline, none of the other content is to be believed??  So that would mean most of the U.K. press at one time or another.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on August 28, 2015, 21:11:49 PM
Funny how often people tell us not to believe what you read in the press. Except when they are telling us not to believe what isn't in the press.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 28, 2015, 21:13:10 PM
After some wine this evening Scunner, had to think about that for a while...  :) 
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 21:24:40 PM

Stories never get 'made up' in Calis/Fethiye do they

I'm not saying Liz made anything up but stories here go round like Chinese whispers.

As for believing a local - why don't you believe one who has lived here all his life and runs a beach bar every single day?




Some would say that if someone ran a beach bar they would tell the tourists that everything is fine. I make no comment   :D

And some would think that someone who ran a beach bar would have a lot to lose if there was crap floating in the sea.

He's already told me and others that he's sure it's the boats and has reported them. What more do you need?

I heard a story first hand the other day. One of our neighbours went on a boat trip and they were told they couldn't dock at one particular, idyllic beach. So the captain emptied the toilet waste, laughed and moved on.

He thought it was hilarious. They thought it was horrible.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 21:27:00 PM
.... and I believe Thomson have poo pood that report!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 28, 2015, 23:00:25 PM
Amazing how Jacqui fails to respond to the fact cruise ships are accused of causing so much pollution in the form of human waste.

I guess it's ok to turn a blind eye if you enjoy the trip
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 28, 2015, 23:51:18 PM
I do know, from a passenger that took a tour, that the cruise ship I was on, had a filteration system of some sort so it did not discharge raw sewage.   
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Blindside on August 29, 2015, 06:52:36 AM
I didn't see any boats coming that close into shore or taking that route? They all seem to head the other way out of Fethiye out to sea.

What's further round the corner away from the hotel? Is that a bay that a boat(s) would visit and therefore could empty their tanks? Or do boats ever sit in the bay directly out from the hotel?

Could it be some kind of surface run off due to the local changes on land?

All a bit weird.

Title: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 29, 2015, 14:42:17 PM
Remember the tide brings things in! It doesn't have to be dropped close to the shore in order for things to reach it.l

Read the article Jacqui! The filtration systems are not always sufficient!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on August 29, 2015, 14:53:33 PM
Funny how often people tell us not to believe what you read in the press. Except when they are telling us not to believe what isn't in the press.
Well I believe the squirrel story.

Squirrels is the name of the Motorized Squad of the Turkish forest rangers whose motor bikes have been fitted with water tanks and foam tanks so they can fight small fires. Don't judge a story by its headline!

http://www.sunexpressnews.com/squirrels-to-extinguish-fire/
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 29, 2015, 16:48:37 PM
I know there are not many cruise liners that come into Fethiye and I know that the cruise liners have to discharge 3 miles out.   So, I am not interested in reading articles about cruise liners.   
It would seem strange that this problem in Koca Calis has only just appeared since the new Resort was built.
Of course, the Sensatori did already discharge sewage in the local canal in Koca Calis, so, I would assume they are the No.1 suspects. 
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: MarKar on August 29, 2015, 19:42:08 PM
We were surprised by the increased amount of local people using the koca end of the beach during the evenings and all day at the weekends.
They are there from early evening until late after, midnight picnicking, (perfectly entitled to do so even if the beach does look like the local tip the following morning). Just a thought......where's the local toilet?.

 Markar
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on August 29, 2015, 19:47:25 PM
Right in front of the beach
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: kevinartois on August 29, 2015, 19:54:07 PM
so to summarize sensatori hasnt got a sewage pipe but jacquies boat did pollute the sea  8)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: MarKar on August 29, 2015, 20:07:38 PM
Right in front of the beach
Spot on  ;)  lol!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 29, 2015, 20:55:49 PM
Strange because my Cruise was a Baltic Cruise.... so the sewage must have drifted a long way.
Sound like Koca Caiis may not the place to be lately, this is going to affect the property market if word gets out   :) 
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: kevinartois on August 29, 2015, 20:59:09 PM
lol : :) :P :-[ :-X :'( :D  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 29, 2015, 22:33:17 PM
Not interested in reading about the filth that cruise liners dump in the sea but can't wait to blame a new hotel for something that's not been proved.

Says it all I think.

Enjoy your pull on the chain next time you are afloat
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: curvanord on August 30, 2015, 08:19:59 AM
Just walked the length of prom and water is clear and inviting with plenty of people in the sea.
I will definitely be venturing in. Hopefully next post won't come from a Calis pharmacy!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on August 30, 2015, 09:17:54 AM
Not interested in reading about the filth that cruise liners dump in the sea but can't wait to blame a new hotel for something that's not been proved.

Says it all I think.

Enjoy your pull on the chain next time you are afloat



No, get it right.   I said I am not interested in reading articles about cruise liners.  However, if you are worried about pollution.  I believe air travel comes into this subject particularly long trips to the States.   
I don't recall anybody complaining about sewage in the sea around Koca Calis until the Sensatori was built.  If  I owned a place next door to this Resort in Koca Calis,  I would be worried and would stop defending this resort at every opportunity and find out exactly what is causing the pollution.
I think I would be making enquiries to find out is it true the resort has been fined for polluting the sea as it was reported in the local press. Perhaps your friends who run the Sensatori F.B. Page might be able to help with this?
The Sensatori have been guilty of polluting the river in Koca Calis this year. This was well documented ( on the Koca Calis F.B. Page you run) by angry residents who seemed to very frustrated with the lack of help from the Resort . I recall reading that the man who was running the campaign against the pollution and was writing all the letters was offered a free week at the Resort..
Is it totally unthinkable that the resort could be implicated again?.  Surely  not,  it must be some random Cruise Ship floating off Koca Calis. 



Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: sarah d on August 31, 2015, 09:24:38 AM
i read this thread before my holiday,and was fearing the worse,i have to say the beach and water was fine my sons did the paragliding and saw no slick, plenty of people in the sea including locals,i asked at guvens if they knew about it,a member of staff said they had seen turds floating in the sea and had collected them broken them in half to see a green interior,turtle turds!
Title: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 31, 2015, 09:53:45 AM
Well well Sarah! I wonder what the Sensatori bashers will make of that?

Barut were guilty of riding roughshod over the locals in Koca Calis and this was unacceptable. We can all hope that they might help keep the waterways clear this winter that their staff part meant block does not become flooded.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on August 31, 2015, 15:13:25 PM
So folks, the next time you're swimming in the sea and see a turd, you must make a point of breaking it in half and checking the colour before commenting in a forum thread about it.  ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on August 31, 2015, 15:53:39 PM
http://mauinow.com/2014/01/29/turtles-named-as-likely-culprit-in-shoreline-waste/
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on August 31, 2015, 16:08:57 PM
Funny how they didn't start pooing there till the hotel opened  ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: desmartinson on August 31, 2015, 16:17:30 PM
We don't care where you are. Calis or the UK, We Will hunt you down. Picking on us for having a Crap. ;D
 
(http://s7.postimg.org/54ct5fvwn/4034628_turtle2106.jpg) (http://postimg.org/image/54ct5fvwn/)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 01, 2015, 11:59:32 AM
The Cruise Ship the Aegean Odyssey is docked in Fethiye today.   So, anyone out swimming  in Koca Calis remember to break up any poos you see and if they are not green inside, they are not from the Turtles so blame the Ship.   :o 8)  :)

(http://s2.postimg.org/ravrt5col/image.jpg) (http://postimg.org/image/ravrt5col/)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 01, 2015, 22:11:31 PM
Raofl - you are comedy gold Jacqui.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 01, 2015, 22:13:55 PM

Funny how they didn't start pooing there till the hotel opened    ;)

Not saying it's the turtles. My money is on the passing boats.

No way is the hotel pumping raw sewerage into the bay IMO.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on September 01, 2015, 22:27:26 PM
But the boats enter the bay and turn right generally, for the harbour and marinas.

i.e. They enter the bay and go the direction opposite to where the "problem" is/was. So how is it not evident in Fethiye Centrum but has been hugely evident where none of the boats you blame go?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 01, 2015, 23:32:19 PM
I also think it strange that this problem has only just occurred, but the Cruise Boats have been passing the area for a long time. 
So, as this problem just recently occurred, is there anything new in the area that could be connected to this pollution? Well I can't think of anything.   It's a total mystery.   :o    ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on September 02, 2015, 06:58:03 AM
Turdgate deepens !
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on September 02, 2015, 08:20:07 AM
Were the turds there before JH started her holiday?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 02, 2015, 08:27:31 AM
Nothing to do with the Harvey's Colwyn, we had a septic tank at our place.   So, it must be you pesky tourist staying in hotels in the area..... So how was the Sensatori ??
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Colwyn on September 02, 2015, 08:52:40 AM
Sensational. I particularly enjoyed watching all our turds being transported out to sea via the magic invisible pipeline, being dodged by the circling cruisers who had to dump their holding tanks before going on to Fethiye (now that the new Buyuksehir charges are so much higher) surrounded by flocks of turtles chomping away.

Actually we were in Edinburgh enjoying the beautiful sunny weather and catching the End of Fringe firework festival.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: mac2010 on September 02, 2015, 09:05:24 AM
A turd a day keeps the tourist away, Maybe we should start a campaign ( Bag it & Tag it) and for everyone collected we could donate 5TL to a local  charity.  ;)  ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on September 02, 2015, 11:15:54 AM
I once heard the firmly held opinion expressed “We never had asylum seekers before the Channel Tunnel was built.”

I really think there is a similar false association being made here between a hotel going up and the problem on the beach.

I do vaguely remember speaking to someone quite a few years ago about nasties that can appear on areas of Calis beaches. It is only now, after a few Face Book postings and bleatings, that the connection to the new hotel has been inferred........ read the first few posts of this thread and see how it all developed from a question to a fact without any proof at all.

Tidal currents, off shore currents winds and tides can mean this stuff could be coming from literally anywhere and any direction. (Think about the message in a bottle game). It isn’t reported in Fethiye Centrum because no one swims there, but there has certainly been talk about the sea at Aksazlar for many years.

As another thought... where is the facility for the Calis Boats to discharge their waste tanks at the quayside in Calis. Has anyone ever seen a tanker hooked up to any of the boats to empty their tanks ( I have occasionally seen one in Fethiye). I am willing to bet a shilling or two that sadly, practically all the Calis boats and a good proportion of the Fethiye boats surreptitiously dump their waste at sea.

Maybe we should start asking them if they do ??

(Or we could start a Face Book page stating that they do dump waste and demanding that everyone boycotts the boats, we could hand out ten thousand leaflets and ask Simon Calder to get involved....... even though we didn’t have any proof and the boats denied it.)

PS : Any one found the pipe yet ??
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 02, 2015, 18:28:20 PM
Phil - I mentioned in an earlier post that a long standing beach bar owner is convinced it's the boats ( he actually named the 12 Island ones).

However it's much better for some to blame the new hotel no matter what evidence they lack.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Daffodil on September 02, 2015, 18:54:56 PM
Casts a whole new light on the New Years Day charity splash! ;D
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 02, 2015, 21:10:32 PM
Whatever is causing this pollution, that must be lowering the prices of property in Koca Calis.
Someone will have to get to the bottom of it.   : :) :-X
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on September 03, 2015, 09:08:12 AM
Yep – it won’t be long before people are saying “The prices in Koca Calis started falling after that hotel and beach pollution story.”

Any falling prices won’t have anything to do with the exchange rate, the state of the British economy, the glut of properties on the market or the lack of good properties on the market, the political situation in Turkey, the uncertainties about Residency, the Turkish cost of living, the mistrust of the Turkish property market or any other of the dozens of factors it could be – it will ALL be down to this fable.................
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on September 03, 2015, 13:09:31 PM
I bet some EKH has started this rumour in the hope that the value of Efes would go into freefall.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 07, 2015, 16:29:43 PM
Well we've all been in the sea today and it was lovely. Nothing floating around - just lovely warm, clear water.

Maybe whoever was dropping the crap has been caught?

Been here three weeks and seen nothing nasty. Maybe lucky but we have been to the beach a few times.
Title: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 07, 2015, 16:30:26 PM
Efes is 6 here
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 07, 2015, 16:32:14 PM
And I think property prices in Turkey will be more governed by the IsIs war than crap in the sea.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: mercury on September 07, 2015, 18:00:37 PM
Which part of Koca Calis was this Stoop. Saw your photo today looked lovely.  Anne
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 07, 2015, 21:49:25 PM
We were at Max's place - Koca Calis Beach Bar.

It really was lovely in the sea. We were all apprehensive after the bad press but it really was lovely.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on September 07, 2015, 23:16:18 PM
I get the impression it was lovely. Was it lovely ?  ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on September 07, 2015, 23:23:23 PM
 Because of course you can see all the bacteria that is contained in water. Clear water = lovely.

I think I'd give it a miss, given the recent contamination caused by the hotel/boat/turtle/whatever. The cause doesn't really matter - nobody disagrees that it was significantly contaminated. Just because you can't see it anymore doesn't mean it's safe yet.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 08, 2015, 12:55:52 PM
Well in that case maybe we should give the sea a miss everywhere. Who knows what bacteria is in there?

We are all more than ok today so I'll take my chances - like lots of others seem to be doing on a daily basis.

...and yes it was lovely KKOB.  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 08, 2015, 14:33:24 PM
We prefer our pool, it is safer.   :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on September 08, 2015, 21:52:38 PM
If anyone is worried about swimming in the beaches of Koca Calis, they must be equally concerned about swimming at Calis Beach and all beaches in the area. The sea is not fenced in. Has anyone taken a sample of water for analysis? There must be a lab in the region...?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on September 08, 2015, 22:23:07 PM
I won't be going in anywhere  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 08, 2015, 22:28:10 PM
We don't do beaches anyway, but pool is lovely and warm like a bath at the moment in the heatwave.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on September 08, 2015, 23:09:33 PM

Well in that case maybe we should give the sea a miss everywhere.


Well I wouldn't go that far, but certainly avoid those sea areas that were full of visible and significant contamination just a few weeks previously.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: kayakebab on September 09, 2015, 06:30:35 AM
A friend saw a nice big poo in the sea in Koca Calis last week.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Lotty on September 09, 2015, 09:00:48 AM
At least it was a 'nice' one Linda! Lol  ;) ;D
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 09, 2015, 09:18:20 AM
Yes, but was it a turtle poo or a human poo.  Also, was it a posh poo from the Sensatori or a common one frm those terrible cruise ships.... Kayakebab, we don't want half a poo story.   ;D  ;) :o :-X :angel:
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on September 09, 2015, 09:27:08 AM
Have you ever thought.......

1. Swimming pools are filled with water that is pumped up from the water table.
2. Houses empty their drains into cesspits in the ground which seep water slowly into .......
   .......... the water table !

Yes, I know swimming pool is treated.

But after a particularly nasty holiday ear infection I took my kids to the doctors and he said that he NEVER swims in a swimming pool. He only swims in the sea.

He maintained that no swimming pool cleaning regime could totally rid a pool totally of all the nasties and he saw loads of problems associated with swimming pool water. His view was that a skip full of nasties in the sea would cause less problems than an egg cup full of nasties in a pool.

Needless to say I still swim in our pool, cross the road, get on a dolmus, ride a bicycle and engage in other hazardous activities including swimming in the sea.

(Don’t forget that you shouldn’t be swimming in the sea in Calis any way ‘cos it’s contaminated with chromium from the old mine working)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 09, 2015, 11:35:03 AM
Our pool is tested every day is very clean.   I would rather trust that that the sea. 
I think you Doctor was speaking about a communal pool. 
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on September 09, 2015, 13:07:13 PM
No – I was there when he said it. “Any pool, any type, anywhere, any country.”
Bit over the top I grant you.

What difference can it possibly make whether the pool is communal or private ?? The problems are the same (ie people).

Pools are tested every day for the correct pH value. They are not tested for any biological or bacterial contamination.
I try not think about what an in depth, laboratory test of any swimming pool water might reveal !


Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 09, 2015, 15:25:03 PM
Because, in communical pools people get in with dirty feet and sweaty bodies.They do not shower first.   Also some kids and maybe some adults wee in communal pools.     
We have had our pool for 10 years now and if we are getting family to stay the pool guy always ask so he can adjust the amount of chemicals etc.,  We have never had any ill effects from the pool.  This year it is just the two of us, so we have no worries.     ;) ;D 8) :angel:

Glad all our famous medal winning swimmers and divers have no problems with pools.  Obviously, they have not visited your Doctor.  :)   :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: scorcher on September 09, 2015, 15:30:27 PM
Never, ever swim in a communical pool!  ;D
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Phil on September 09, 2015, 16:50:57 PM
Did actually ask the Doc how Olympic swimmers survived and he said that apparently Recreational Water Illnesses (even had an acronym for it - RWI’s ) were quite a problem for them........

He made such an impression on me that I did do quite a bit of research about swimming pool water and its maintenance – I’ll dig some of it out and post it later. It certainly made me have a lot more cautious approach to ALL swimming pools (including my own).

But I am pleased to say that on Sunday I will be able to jump in ours again.
Title: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 10, 2015, 11:39:43 AM
Well the sea has a great way of cleansing due to the salt levels. But even if we go down the path that two or three weeks ago there was poo in the water the fact is it will be all over Calis due to the way the tide goes from west to east. Any poo in Koca would move pretty quickly to Calis Beach and Fethiye.

Not a poo expert but I would think turtle poo is pretty harmless due to their diet?

Maybe someone knows?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Scunner on September 10, 2015, 14:51:39 PM
Why do you assume it has to be a turtle poo?
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 10, 2015, 15:10:30 PM
Because  he took it out of the water and broke it open and it must have been green inside.   :) 
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on September 10, 2015, 15:35:25 PM
It could have been whale poo, or shark poo, or not poo at all.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: villain on September 10, 2015, 16:44:33 PM
I wee in the sea all the time. (Well not ALL the time, but you know what I mean)

Is that wrong?

Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 10, 2015, 17:05:20 PM
I wee in the sea all the time. (Well not ALL the time, but you know what I mean)

Is that wrong?




Think you need Jeremy Kyle not Calis Beach Forum to answer that one   :)  Shame Claire Rayner is no longer with us.   ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Lotty on September 10, 2015, 19:28:24 PM
Yes - Yes! I always worry about those warm patches when you swim off the boat trips,  now I KNOW it was you Villain . . . He-hehe!    ;)  ;D
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on September 10, 2015, 21:21:04 PM
I'm beginning to think twice about swimming off the boat trips which up until reading this topic, I used to look forward to on every trip. Every stop there are a group of boats - maybe each offloading unmentionables - .

If I can't swim in the polluted sea around Calis, the boat trips are a no-no and the swimming pools are a danger to health, and Jacqui keeps implying us that Koca Calis isn't the little paradise I've come to love  even though we haven't experienced these floods you're talking about,  heck - maybe buying the villa wasn't such a good idea (and that buying process hasn't exactly been a piece of cake - as you can see if you've been reading my blog "Buying the Dream". Oh dear! :'(
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Lotty on September 10, 2015, 21:31:18 PM
Oops! a bit heavy there ArtyMar?  but really it was just a bit of a light joke with Villain! I'm sure it's ok to swim from the boats out in the bay!  ;D ;D
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on September 10, 2015, 21:57:40 PM
I know, Lotty! I was only kidding! In a couple of weeks, I'll be swimming in our pool and in the sea - and off the boat if we go on one this time 8)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 11, 2015, 11:07:20 AM
I never said I assumed it was turtle poo but someone did mention that one beach bar had taken one out near his place, broken it in two and proved it was not human waste.

What I was saying is that I think turtle poo is harmless but I'm not 100% certain without checking.

There are also more than a few big turtles in the area.

My opinion is that it was probably human waste from the boats dumping their load and maybe mixed with the inevitable turtle poo in the area. Whatever it was I saw no evidence of it in the three weeks and a bit we were in Koca Calis. The sea looked exactly the same as it has done the previous 12 years we have stayed there.

Maybe they are dumping it elsewhere now or the culprits have decided to clean up their act and pay to dump their waste in harbour.
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: KKOB on September 11, 2015, 11:40:03 AM
Are you using the words "dump" and "dumping" on purpose ?   ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: curvanord on September 11, 2015, 12:06:05 PM
http://youtu.be/tTE1rCcMaZY
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: ArtyMar on September 11, 2015, 12:11:29 PM
Ha ha! Brilliant!
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 11, 2015, 16:05:41 PM
KKOB - yes I am because the general term for the place to dispose of waste from a boat or motor home, etc is a Dump Station.

No pun intended by the person who named it I'm sure  ;)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Lynne09 on September 11, 2015, 16:33:38 PM
Been on Calis beach today saw sewage floating in sea will be staying round my pool for the rest of the holiday very worrying
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: IanK on September 11, 2015, 16:38:35 PM
In fact, the boating fraternity usually refer to this as a "pump out station".

In turkey, there is legislation regarding their use and the pump out should be recorded on a Blue Card - as a way of tracking that you are actually using them.

You are not even supposed to drain your washing up water into the sea - never mind anything more serious.

How well this is enforced  is another matter of course.

Ian
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: Jacqui Harvey on September 11, 2015, 17:13:17 PM
We were in Russian on a cruise ship for two days and the laundries on the ship were all locked up.  Not even soap suds allowed. 
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: johntaylor49 on September 13, 2015, 08:46:39 AM
Been on Calis beach today saw sewage floating in sea will be staying round my pool for the rest of the holiday very worrying
Where exactly Lynne? I have been looking carefully at the sea from the Letoon Hotel along as far as Sunset Beach and actually looked pretty clean now. Folks about the Turtle Poo I believe that the human is the only animal whose waste is so dangerous generally in that it can carry so many harmful bacteria. In fact in the army we were taught that in dire emergency cow pat could be used as a wound dressing as when fresh it is sterile! All mammal poo takes longer to degrade than other animals. No poo is good to ingest. I explained this to a friend in Calis but he poo-pooed the idea  :)
Title: Re: Sea pollution ????
Post by: stoop on September 14, 2015, 08:54:25 AM
I looked for three weeks and saw nothing. Wasn't in the sea every day though